This essay was originally posted under the title “Jewish Music” on my “The Second Son” blogspot blog. It's a (now extensive) side-by-side comparisons of some of the songs circulating in the Yeshivish community that are widely accepted as authentically Jewish, next to the original versions. I’ve periodically updated the post. Over a decade later, this is still the most popular thing I’ve ever written.
In my experience, the top tier of Gedolim never occupied themselves with this topic. Only the level 2 wannabes and some Mesivta Rebbeim.
The idea that the frum world rejects goyishe music as a shita is like saying the frum world rejects long sheitels as a shita. Lots of noise, but no substance.
The goyishe music scene is, of course, unacceptable. Correctly, no Yeshiva can tolerate its talmidim as music devotees, fans, or groupies.
Frankly, including Country Yossi, Shlock Rock, AKA Pella, Maccabeats, Six13, or even Uncle Moishy are kind of unfair because those are explicitly parodies. It's the MBD ones that are surprising.
In my experience, the top tier of Gedolim never occupied themselves with this topic. Only the level 2 wannabes and some Mesivta Rebbeim.
The idea that the frum world rejects goyishe music as a shita is like saying the frum world rejects long sheitels as a shita. Lots of noise, but no substance.
The goyishe music scene is, of course, unacceptable. Correctly, no Yeshiva can tolerate its talmidim as music devotees, fans, or groupies.
Except Waterbury
https://youtu.be/nZ8oOHjsSxQ?si=ckAyUz3RTa8G-tsG
Surely has to feature
The intro and interlude of 'It's what I believe' from Journeys III sounds quite similar to the intro of 'Piano man' by Billy Joel.
Do I know more!? There's tons!
Here's two great places to start:
https://forums.dansdeals.com/index.php?topic=6792.0;topicseen
https://open.spotify.com/playlist/2C1R6KRDa4FZ2GpkGLWQGX?si=eTGsTTGWQji3cvlnjgMpgA
Frankly, including Country Yossi, Shlock Rock, AKA Pella, Maccabeats, Six13, or even Uncle Moishy are kind of unfair because those are explicitly parodies. It's the MBD ones that are surprising.
Most of these aren't chiddushim at all to anyone a bit worldly.
And the mama Rachel comparison is lazy and weak with very little connection and is blasphemous against good ole Abie who has actual talent lol